Apr 5, 2013; Los Angeles, CA, USA; Memphis Grizzlies power forward Ed Davis (32) goes up for a lay up while defended by Los Angeles Lakers point guard Steve Blake (5) during the second quarter at the Staples Center. Mandatory Credit: Jake Roth-USA TODAY Sports

Do Raps miss Ed Davis more than Jose Calderon?

The Toronto Raptors have now played 31 games since Ed Davis and Jose Calderon were traded to Memphis for Rudy Gay. That’s sufficient time to draw some conclusions. I’ve already expressed how the loss of Jose has damaged our favourite team; I don’t plan to plough that ground again. Instead, I’m going to explore the possibility that taking Ed Davis out of our roster was a bigger mistake than has been recognized.

Apr 6, 2013; Milwaukee, WI, USA; Toronto Raptors forward Amir Johnson (15) taps a rebound during the first quarter against the Milwaukee Bucks at the BMO Harris Bradley Center. Mandatory Credit: Jeff Hanisch-USA TODAY Sports

The only decent segment of the Raps’ schedule commenced on December 14 with a home victory over Dallas. From then until the trade on January 30, the Raps were 12-10. Since the trade, which was billed as the big move to push us into playoff contention, the Raps are 12-19. The playoffs, a mathematical longshot when Rudy arrived, are now officially toast. What’s worse, if that’s possible, is the fact the Raps have floundered against the league’s worst teams. We’ve lost to Charlotte, Detroit, Cleveland and twice to Washington. In short, this trade has been a disaster.

So what’s gone wrong? Let’s answer that by glancing at a 3-win stretch over the Christmas holidays against New Orleans, Orlando and Portland. In those games, Ed Davis averaged 17 points and 6 rebounds, while Amir Johnson contributed 12 and 6. But it wasn’t just the points those two were consistently providing – it was how they were getting them. Amir and Ed were getting noticed around the NBA for their ability to create high-percentage shots for each other. Amir would receive the ball at the foul line just as Ed was cutting to the hoop – a quick dish from Amir and presto, easy bucket for Ed. The young power forward received his chance after Andrea Bargnani’s elbow injury, and he was making the most of it. The two bigs were relieving the scoring pressure from the backs of DeMar DeRozan and Kyle Lowry.

Apr 6, 2013; Milwaukee, WI, USA; Toronto Raptors guard Kyle Lowry (3) drives for a layup against Milwaukee Bucks center Larry Sanders (8) during the first quarter at the BMO Harris Bradley Center. Mandatory Credit: Jeff Hanisch-USA TODAY Sports

To me, this is the crux of the matter. When Ed was dealt away, the Raps lost some scoring balance between their back and front court players, and that precious equilibrium may never return. Now Ed languishes on the bench in Memphis, Jose is playing out the string in Motown, and the Raps are dysfunctional. Who won this trade anyway?

We’ll explore the impact of the trade on the Raps’ present and future roster tomorrow.

Brian Boake is an editor for Raptors Rapture. “Like” Raptors Rapture on Facebook and follow us on Twitter @RaptorsRapture for all the latest news and updates about the best damn NBA team from Canada.


Tags: Detroit Pistons Ed Davis Jose Calderon Memphis Grizzlies Toronto Raptors

  • Hoopgirl1st

    Great prospective! I miss Jose (most important player for the Raptors since Alvin Wiliams) for all the reasons that have already been posted and voiced. I was really shocked that we traded Eddie, who had become such a valuable piece of our front 3, especially as his development (which was the surprise and delight of the season for Raptor fans) has now been completely curtailed with his near permanent spot on the Grizzlies bench. The trade of these two players was a setback to Eddie’s development and a dagger to the heart of Raptor’s fans.

    • Newmarket_Brian

      Hi Hoopgirl: Hear, Hear to everything you’ve written. This is the rare trade that hasn’t helped any of the teams involved, nor the players. Even Jose can’t lift the Pistons out of the Pits, where they’ve been for a long time. Ed is stuck behind Zach Randolph in Memphis, and Rudy has been a huge disappointment with our group.
      Big yuck!
      Thanks for commenting.

  • Greg Hall

    I also miss Ed Davis, he would have been our starting PF for the remainder of the sesaon (not that Amir Johnson hasn’t been great because he has) but Amir was really needed for depth behind JV and Ed in case either got into foul trouble and to give them a blow, the front court was severely depleted all season and that’s a tough way to win basketball games, even with the smaller lineups out there these days.

    • Newmarket_Brian

      Amir is terrific for many reasons, one of which being that he doesn’t care whether he starts or comes off the bench. Ed is one of those players who needs to start, I believe. It’s a psychological thing, and shouldn’t be construed as a character flaw. I hope his career doesn’t wither on the vine in Memphis, but it might.
      Thanks for commenting.