The Toronto Raptors have a point guard problem. After paying Immanuel Quickley all that money back in the 2024 offseason, he never turned into the lead guard the front office believed he could be when they invested in him as a core piece of their future. The biggest issue with the Raptors’ Quickley puzzle has been that even though he can be a natural off-ball scoring fit next to Scottie Barnes, he doesn’t have the typical traits you need from a lead guard.
Sure, Quickley can fill it up and be the type of scorer that can get blistering hot, but as Toronto's lead guard, his best trait is off-ball scoring isn’t what Toronto needs. Yes, his scoring ability provides value to this team and can help swing games in Toronto's favor at times, but the sentiment so many of us have echoed is that Toronto needs more from him.
But what if we are looking at the Raptors' point guard issues the wrong way? What if it’s not an IQ issue, but a roster-construction issue? What if Toronto explored adding a true point guard to the mix and had Quickley play the two? Could that work? Maybe not perfectly, but it may be much better.
Raptors should consider moving Immanuel Quickley off the ball permanently
Look at Jamal Murray, for example, and his situation with the Denver Nuggets. He’s always been a score-first guard who plays mostly off his team's star, Nikola Jokic. However, he still has the lead guard handle and playmaking chops to create for his teammates at a high level if needed. Although IQ and Murray are on different levels, they share similar score-first tendencies. The difference is that Murray has the playmaking chops to operate as a legitimate lead guard when needed, something Quickley has yet to consistently demonstrate.
So it’s time for the front office to accept that he is an off-guard and find a new lead guard to run the show and set up IQ and the rest of the team.
Over the past year, we’ve seen Immanuel Quickley really thrive in the minutes where Darko Rajakovic stacks his minutes with Jamal Shead.
Having Shead in the game lightens Quickley’s load and lets him focus on what he does best: playing off someone else and scoring. Shead’s playmaking chops are elite, and he’s super experienced running an offense, but the issue with having him outright take that starting spot next to IQ in the backcourt is that his scoring efficiency remains a concern. Despite being a pitbull defender and very tough, Shead can still get hunted because of his size, and having him and IQ out there to start games can be free food for opponents.
When we talk about upgrading the point guard position, the name that always comes up is Quickley, but if Toronto were to test the theory I’m proposing, the odd man out becomes RJ Barrett. Obviously, it's pretty ironic that I'm proposing yet another concept that involves dealing Barrett. But given his recent play, it makes sense, and with him being on an expiring contract, taking on Barrett's contract may be easier for opposing GMs to stomach than Quick’s contract.
I’m not suggesting that Quickley starting at the two alongside a new point guard fixes everything, but the Raptors are running out of options, and in order to maximize him, they may have to consider testing out this theory.
